Questions to Ask About Spending, Taxes, Debt, and Government Programs
A Practical Christian Guide for Looking Beyond Political Promises and Asking Where the Money Comes From, Where It Goes, Whether a Program Works, and Who Will Bear the Cost
Government finance can be confusing.
Millions of dollars quickly become billions.
Billions become trillions.
Politicians announce new programs, tax cuts, tax increases, grants, benefits, subsidies, investments, savings, and spending reductions.
One side may describe a proposal as an essential investment.
Another may call the same proposal wasteful spending.
One candidate may promise to lower taxes.
Another may promise additional government services.
A politician may say a program will “pay for itself.”
An advertisement may claim that a proposal will cost the average taxpayer almost nothing.
Another advertisement may warn that the same proposal will destroy the economy.
How is an ordinary citizen supposed to evaluate these claims?
Christians do not need to become economists or government accountants before participating in public life.
But responsible citizenship requires more than deciding whether a political promise sounds appealing.
We can learn to ask good questions.
Scripture repeatedly commends wisdom, careful planning, honesty, and faithful stewardship.
Proverbs says:
“The naive believes everything, but the sensible man considers his steps.” – Proverbs 14:15 (NASB 1995)
That principle is especially useful in political life.
We should not believe something merely because our preferred candidate says it.
We should not reject something merely because the opposing party proposes it.
We should investigate.
Ask questions.
Compare claims with evidence.
Consider costs.
Examine results.

Responsible citizens look beyond political promises by asking where public money comes from, where it goes, whether programs work, who bears the cost, and what obligations are being passed to future generations.
Begin With the Most Basic Question: What Exactly Is Being Proposed?
Before deciding whether you support a government proposal, make sure you understand it.
Political arguments often begin with labels.
“Tax relief.”
“Investment.”
“Spending cut.”
“Entitlement reform.”
“Corporate welfare.”
“Universal benefit.”
“Public-private partnership.”
“Emergency funding.”
“Tax loophole.”
“Infrastructure.”
“Government waste.”
These phrases may describe something important, but the label does not tell you everything.
Ask:
What specifically will the government do?
Who will receive the money or benefit?
Who will administer it?
How much will it cost?
How long will it last?
What law creates or authorizes it?
Is it a new program or an expansion of an existing one?
Is participation temporary or permanent?
The more specific the question becomes, the easier it is to evaluate the proposal responsibly.
What Problem Is the Government Trying to Solve?
Before asking how much a program costs, understand why it exists.
What problem is being addressed?
How many people are affected?
How serious is the problem?
Is the problem temporary or continuing?
Is it primarily local, state, or national?
What happens if nothing is done?
Is government already addressing the same problem through another program?
A program should not be evaluated only by its price.
A very inexpensive program can still be unnecessary.
A very expensive program can sometimes address a legitimate and costly public responsibility.
Cost matters, but purpose matters too.
Is This a Legitimate Responsibility of Government?
Before discussing the size of the appropriation, ask whether government should be undertaking the responsibility at all.
Could the matter reasonably be handled by:
Individuals?
Families?
Churches?
Charities?
Businesses?
Community organizations?
Local government?
State government?
Or does it require federal action?
Romans teaches that civil authority has a legitimate role in maintaining order and responding to wrongdoing.
Paul wrote:
“For it is a minister of God to you for good.” – Romans 13:4 (NASB 1995)
That does not mean Scripture authorizes every modern government program.
It means government has legitimate responsibilities.
Christians must use wisdom when determining how biblical principles apply to particular modern policies.
Which Level of Government Should Pay for It?
Even when something is a legitimate public responsibility, another question remains:
Which government?
City?
County?
State?
Federal?
A local road may be primarily a local or state concern.
National defense belongs to the federal government.
Education may involve local school systems, state governments, and federal requirements.
Disaster response may begin locally and expand when local and state resources are overwhelmed.
Do not assume that because government should address something, the federal government necessarily should.
Likewise, do not assume every responsibility can realistically remain local.
Match the scale of the response to the scale and nature of the problem.
How Much Will It Really Cost?
Politicians frequently emphasize an initial price.
Citizens should ask for the fuller cost.
What will it cost this year?
Next year?
Over five years?
Over ten years?
Will the cost increase automatically?
Does the estimate include administration?
Employees?
Buildings?
Technology?
Maintenance?
Benefits?
Contractors?
Interest?
Compliance?
Future obligations?
A program that appears inexpensive at its beginning may become substantially more expensive as participation grows.
Is the Cost a One-Time Expense or a Continuing Obligation?
This distinction is extremely important.
Suppose government spends money to repair a bridge after a disaster.
That may be largely a one-time expense.
Now suppose government creates a new permanent benefit.
That may require funding every year indefinitely.
Ask:
Is this temporary spending or a permanent commitment?
If temporary, when does it end?
If permanent, how will it be funded in future years?
Temporary money should not quietly create permanent obligations without citizens understanding what is happening.
Where Will the Money Come From?
This should be one of the most common questions citizens ask.
A government proposal may be funded through:
Existing tax revenue.
A new tax.
A higher tax rate.
Fees.
Borrowing.
Reduced spending elsewhere.
Transfers from another government fund.
Grants from another level of government.
Some combination of these.
“Government will pay for it” is not a complete answer.
Ask:
Where will government get the money?
If Taxes Increase, Who Will Pay More?
A tax increase should be examined carefully.
Which tax?
Income tax?
Sales tax?
Property tax?
Payroll tax?
Corporate tax?
Capital-gains tax?
Gasoline tax?
Excise tax?
Estate tax?
Special assessment?
User fee?
Who is legally responsible for paying it?
Who may ultimately bear some of its economic cost?
Will the tax affect prices?
Employment?
Investment?
Housing?
Retirement?
Small businesses?
Families?
Economic behavior?
The answers will differ depending upon the particular tax.
Avoid sweeping assumptions.
If Taxes Are Cut, What Happens to Revenue and Spending?
Tax reductions deserve the same scrutiny as tax increases.
Ask:
How much revenue is expected to be reduced?
Will spending also be reduced?
Which spending?
Is additional economic growth expected?
What evidence supports that projection?
Will borrowing increase if projected revenue does not materialize?
Who receives the tax reduction?
A tax cut may be wise.
But saying “lower taxes” does not eliminate the need to count the cost.
Is This Actually a Tax—or Is It a Fee?
Governments sometimes finance services through fees rather than broad taxes.
Licensing fees.
Tolls.
Permit fees.
Court fees.
Utility fees.
Park fees.
Vehicle fees.
These may appropriately connect the cost of a service with people using it.
But citizens should ask:
Is the fee reasonably related to the service?
Is it being used primarily to raise general revenue?
Does it place an excessive burden on low-income citizens?
Has the fee increased repeatedly without adequate explanation?
The label does not determine whether the charge is reasonable.
What Does “The Rich Will Pay for It” Actually Mean?
Political discussions often promise that a program can be financed by taxing wealthy individuals or large corporations.
Citizens should ask for specifics.
Who qualifies as wealthy?
What income level?
What assets?
What tax rate?
How much revenue is expected?
Is that revenue sufficient to fund the promised program?
What behavioral changes are expected?
Could taxpayers change investments, business structures, location, or timing of income?
This does not mean higher-income citizens should never pay higher taxes.
It means slogans should be converted into numbers.
What Does “Middle-Class Tax Cut” Actually Mean?
The same scrutiny applies to tax-cut promises.
Who qualifies?
What income range?
How much does the typical household save?
Does the proposal change deductions or credits?
Does it expire?
Does another tax or fee increase elsewhere?
How will the government replace lost revenue if spending remains unchanged?
Ask for the complete picture rather than the campaign phrase.
Is the Spending Already in the Budget?
A politician may announce a new initiative without clearly explaining whether it requires additional spending.
Ask:
Is this already funded?
Will another program lose funding?
Will taxes increase?
Will reserves be used?
Will debt increase?
Will future budgets have to continue funding it?
A proposal can sound inexpensive if only the new portion is discussed.
Is This a Grant?
Government grants often sound like free money.
A city may announce:
“We received a $5 million federal grant.”
That may be beneficial.
But citizens should ask:
Where did the federal government obtain the money?
Does the local government have to provide matching funds?
What conditions come with the grant?
What must the city maintain after the grant expires?
Will additional employees be required?
Who pays their salaries later?
Would the community choose this project if it had to pay the full cost itself?
A grant may be worthwhile.
But it is not free.
Is This New Spending—or Money That Was Already Going to Be Spent?
Political announcements sometimes make existing funding sound new.
Ask whether the money represents:
A new appropriation.
Previously authorized money.
A reallocation.
An annual program.
Emergency funding.
A grant already expected.
Understanding the source prevents politicians of any party from receiving credit for money they did not actually create.
Is the Program Duplicating Something That Already Exists?
Government programs can accumulate over many years.
Before creating another one, ask:
Does another city, county, state, or federal program already address this problem?
Do multiple agencies perform similar functions?
Could existing programs be coordinated or consolidated?
Would reforming an existing program work better than creating another?
New programs should not automatically be the first response to old problems.
How Much Goes to Administration?
Every program requires administration.
Employees must process applications.
Technology systems must operate.
Records must be maintained.
Fraud must be investigated.
Audits must occur.
Administration is not automatically waste.
But citizens should ask:
How much of the money reaches the intended purpose?
How much supports administration?
Are administrative costs reasonable?
Are several agencies performing similar administrative work?
Efficiency matters because every unnecessary administrative dollar is unavailable for the program’s actual purpose.
How Will Fraud and Abuse Be Prevented?
Large programs involving large amounts of money attract people who attempt to exploit them.
Ask:
What verification is required?
Who audits the program?
Are payments reviewed?
Can citizens report suspected fraud?
Are contractors monitored?
Are conflicts of interest disclosed?
What happens when fraud is discovered?
How much fraud has occurred previously?
Fraud prevention should be strong without making legitimate assistance unnecessarily difficult to obtain.
How Will We Know Whether the Program Works?
This may be the most neglected question.
Government often reports how much money was spent.
But spending is not success.
Ask:
What outcome is the program supposed to produce?
If the goal is reducing homelessness, did homelessness decrease?
If the goal is improving reading, did reading improve?
If the goal is reducing repeat crime, did recidivism decline?
If the goal is helping people find employment, did participants obtain and maintain jobs?
If the goal is improving a road, was the project completed properly and on budget?
Measure results, not announcements.
What Is the Cost Per Result?
Suppose two programs help people find employment.
Program A spends $10 million and helps 10,000 people.
Program B spends $10 million and helps 1,000 people.
Those numbers do not tell us everything.
The populations may be different.
One group may face much greater barriers.
But asking the cost per successful outcome can reveal important information.
Government should seek effective results, not simply larger budgets.
Who Determines Whether the Program Succeeded?
The agency operating a program may naturally want to demonstrate success.
Independent evaluation can be valuable.
Ask:
Are results audited?
Is the data public?
Can independent researchers examine it?
Are performance standards established before the program begins?
Does the legislature review results?
Is an inspector general involved?
Accountability is stronger when institutions do not grade themselves entirely.
What Happens If the Program Does Not Work?
Before creating a program, ask:
What happens if it fails?
Will it be changed?
Reduced?
Ended?
Will officials simply request more money?
Will the original goals be reconsidered?
Programs should not become permanent merely because government has already spent money on them.
Does the Program Have an End Date?
Some programs address permanent responsibilities.
Others address temporary circumstances.
For temporary programs, ask whether there is a sunset provision.
When does it expire?
What evidence must be presented before renewal?
Will lawmakers have to vote again?
Emergency programs especially deserve clear review dates.
Is an “Emergency” Still an Emergency?
Emergency spending can be necessary.
Natural disasters.
Wars.
Economic crises.
Public-health emergencies.
Other extraordinary circumstances.
But emergency designations can sometimes bypass normal budget discipline.
Ask:
What is the emergency?
How long has it existed?
When will emergency spending end?
Should this expense now be included in the ordinary budget?
A recurring predictable expense is not necessarily an emergency simply because labeling it that way makes funding easier.
What Happens When the Grant or Temporary Funding Ends?
This question is particularly important for local governments, schools, nonprofits, and public agencies.
Temporary money may fund:
New employees.
Programs.
Technology.
Buildings.
Equipment.
Services.
When the outside money disappears, someone must decide:
End the program?
Lay off employees?
Reduce services?
Raise local taxes?
Use another funding source?
Citizens should understand the exit plan before temporary funding is accepted.
Are We Borrowing for This?
Borrowing changes the question from:
“Can we afford this today?”
to:
“Can we and future taxpayers afford the repayment?”
Ask:
How much is being borrowed?
At what interest rate?
For how long?
What will the total repayment be?
What asset or benefit will remain?
Are future generations receiving something of lasting value?
Borrowing to build infrastructure that serves people for decades is different from continually borrowing to cover ordinary expenses.
What Is the Interest Cost?
Debt costs more than the amount borrowed.
Interest must also be paid.
As government debt grows, interest can consume resources that could otherwise fund:
Defense.
Infrastructure.
Healthcare.
Education.
Public safety.
Tax relief.
Debt reduction.
Other priorities.
Citizens should pay attention not only to total debt but to the cost of servicing that debt.
Is Debt Growing Faster Than Our Ability to Pay?
A large government and a small government cannot be evaluated using the dollar amount of debt alone.
Citizens should consider debt in relation to the government’s economy, revenues, obligations, interest costs, and ability to repay.
Ask whether the current financial path is sustainable.
If debt continues growing faster than the resources available to support it, eventually difficult choices become unavoidable.
Are We Paying Today’s Bills With Tomorrow’s Money?
Borrowing can sometimes distribute the cost of a long-lived investment across generations that benefit from it.
But borrowing for ordinary current expenses deserves special scrutiny.
Ask:
Are future taxpayers helping pay for something they will use?
or:
Are we simply asking them to pay bills we are unwilling to pay ourselves?
Future generations deserve consideration even though they cannot vote today.
Are There Unfunded Promises?
Governments sometimes promise future benefits without setting aside enough resources to pay for them.
Pensions.
Retiree healthcare.
Other long-term obligations.
Ask:
How much has been promised?
How much has been funded?
What assumptions are being used?
What happens if investment returns or revenues are lower than expected?
Who bears the risk?
A promise made today can become a taxpayer obligation decades later.
What Assumptions Are Behind the Numbers?
Budget projections depend upon assumptions.
Economic growth.
Inflation.
Interest rates.
Population.
Employment.
Tax revenue.
Program participation.
Healthcare costs.
Investment returns.
Ask:
What happens if the assumptions are wrong?
A plan that works only under unusually optimistic assumptions may be fragile.
Are Politicians Using the Same Time Period When Comparing Numbers?
Statistics can mislead without being technically false.
One politician may discuss annual cost.
Another discusses ten-year cost.
One may use inflation-adjusted dollars.
Another uses current dollars.
One may compare total spending.
Another compares spending per person.
Before comparing claims, make sure the numbers measure the same thing over the same period.
Is Spending Actually Being Cut—or Is Its Growth Being Reduced?
This causes enormous political confusion.
Suppose a program is projected to grow from $100 million to $120 million.
A proposal changes future spending to $110 million.
One side may call that a $10 million cut because it is $10 million below the previous projection.
Another may say spending actually increased by $10 million compared with today’s level.
Both statements can describe different comparisons.
Ask:
Compared with what?
Understanding the baseline matters.
What Does “Fully Paid For” Mean?
When politicians claim that legislation is fully paid for, ask:
Through what taxes?
What spending reductions?
What fees?
What projected savings?
Over what period?
Are temporary provisions being compared with permanent revenue?
Does the estimate depend upon assumptions about future lawmakers?
Whenever you hear “paid for,” find out how.
What Does “No Cost to Taxpayers” Mean?
Be especially careful with this phrase.
It may mean:
No new appropriation.
Funding comes from an existing fund.
A fee pays for it.
Borrowing pays for it.
Another level of government pays for it.
A private entity pays initially.
None of these necessarily means there is literally no cost.
Ask where the resources originate.
Who Benefits?
Identify the people who receive the direct benefit.
Low-income families?
Middle-income families?
High-income households?
Businesses?
Farmers?
Students?
Older adults?
People with disabilities?
Veterans?
Local governments?
A particular industry?
Everyone?
Knowing who benefits is necessary for evaluating whether a program accomplishes its stated purpose.
Who Does Not Qualify?
Eligibility rules matter.
Two families with very similar circumstances may fall on opposite sides of an eligibility line.
Ask:
What determines eligibility?
Income?
Age?
Disability?
Employment?
Family size?
Geography?
Assets?
Citizenship or legal status?
Other criteria?
Are the rules reasonable and understandable?
Does the Program Create a Benefits Cliff?
Suppose a family receives several forms of assistance.
A modest increase in earnings could cause several benefits to disappear at once.
The family may actually become financially worse off after earning more.
That is a benefits cliff.
Ask whether programs phase out gradually enough to encourage work and advancement.
Compassionate assistance should, where possible, create a bridge toward stability rather than a barrier to progress.
Does the Program Help People Who Cannot Help Themselves?
Some citizens genuinely cannot become fully self-supporting.
Severe disability.
Advanced age.
Serious illness.
Certain caregiving situations.
Other circumstances.
Personal responsibility should always be considered in light of actual ability.
A responsible society should distinguish between unwillingness and inability.
Christians should advocate both compassion and truth.
Does the Program Encourage Personal Responsibility Where Possible?
When people are able, programs may appropriately encourage:
Employment.
Education.
Training.
Treatment.
Budgeting.
Saving.
Family responsibility.
Compliance with reasonable program requirements.
The purpose should not be punishment.
The goal should be helping people move toward greater stability where realistically possible.
Does the Program Strengthen or Weaken Families?
Ask whether program rules affect:
Marriage.
Household formation.
Caregiving.
Parental responsibility.
Childcare.
Saving.
Work.
Family support.
A policy may have unintended effects on family decisions even when family structure was not the subject of the program.
Those effects deserve consideration.
Could the Church, Community, or Private Sector Do Part of This Better?
Government does not have to choose between doing everything and doing nothing.
Sometimes government may handle one part while:
Churches provide personal support.
Nonprofits provide specialized services.
Businesses provide employment.
Families provide care.
Community organizations provide local knowledge.
Ask which institution is best equipped for each part of the need.
Is Government Crowding Out Something That Already Works?
A government program may unintentionally replace:
Private charity.
Family support.
Community organizations.
Private insurance.
Local initiatives.
Business investment.
That is not always harmful.
Sometimes public action is necessary because existing efforts are inadequate.
But policymakers should ask whether government is strengthening effective institutions or unnecessarily displacing them.
What Are the Unintended Consequences?
Before supporting a program, ask:
What could happen that policymakers do not intend?
Could prices increase?
Could housing supply decrease?
Could hiring decline?
Could small businesses face disproportionate costs?
Could fraud increase?
Could people change behavior to qualify for benefits?
Could marriage be unintentionally penalized?
Could saving be discouraged?
Could local control be weakened?
Could privacy be reduced?
Could temporary assistance become permanent dependency?
Could a regulation strengthen the very large companies it was intended to restrain?
We cannot predict everything.
But we can ask.
What Are the Tradeoffs?
Every public decision involves tradeoffs.
More money for one purpose means less money available for another unless revenue or borrowing increases.
Greater security may sometimes affect privacy.
More regulation may increase protection while increasing compliance costs.
Faster approval may reduce oversight.
Stronger oversight may slow action.
Wise policy acknowledges tradeoffs instead of pretending they do not exist.
What Is the Cost of Doing Nothing?
Fiscal responsibility does not mean automatically opposing spending.
Sometimes failing to act costs more.
Ignoring infrastructure maintenance can produce expensive failures.
Untreated addiction can lead to repeated emergency care or incarceration.
Failure to prevent fraud can cost more than oversight.
Delayed repairs may become major reconstruction.
Ask both:
“What does action cost?”
and:
“What does inaction cost?”
What Are the Alternatives?
Do not evaluate a proposal only against an imaginary world where the problem does not exist.
Ask:
Could the program be smaller?
Could it be local?
Could it be temporary?
Could eligibility be better targeted?
Could an existing program be reformed?
Could a nonprofit or business partnership work?
Could regulation be simplified?
Could a pilot program test the idea first?
Could resources be redirected from something less effective?
There are often more than two choices.
Has This Been Tried Somewhere Else?
Look for evidence.
Another city.
Another state.
Another country.
Another school district.
Another government agency.
Ask:
What happened?
How much did it cost?
What results occurred?
What unintended consequences appeared?
How similar are the circumstances?
What changes were later made?
Past experience cannot answer every question, but it can improve present decisions.
What Do Independent Auditors Say?
Government audits can reveal information that campaign advertisements rarely mention.
Auditors may identify:
Improper payments.
Weak internal controls.
Unnecessary expenditures.
Contract problems.
Missing documentation.
Fraud risks.
Programs that do not measure outcomes adequately.
Citizens should learn to look beyond politicians’ descriptions of their own performance.
What Does the Actual Budget Say?
If an issue is important to you, look for the government’s actual budget.
Many cities, counties, states, school systems, and federal agencies publish budgets online.
You do not have to understand every page.
Look for:
Total revenue.
Total expenditures.
Major spending categories.
Debt.
Capital projects.
Personnel costs.
Changes from the previous year.
Long-term obligations.
Budget summaries are often designed for ordinary citizens.
Follow the Money
When a public issue becomes controversial, ask:
Who receives the money?
Government agency?
Private contractor?
Nonprofit?
Consulting company?
Local government?
Individual recipients?
Business?
University?
School system?
Then ask:
What was promised?
What was delivered?
Were contracts competitively awarded?
Were conflicts of interest disclosed?
Was the work completed?
Public spending should be traceable.
Learn Who Actually Voted for the Spending
Campaign rhetoric can be very different from governing records.
A politician may describe himself as fiscally conservative while repeatedly voting for increased spending.
Another may be portrayed as supporting large spending increases when the actual voting record shows something more complicated.
Do not rely only on advertisements.
Look for:
Official roll-call votes.
Government legislative websites.
Committee records.
Budget votes.
Appropriations votes.
Amendments.
Vetoes.
Executive budget proposals.
Then consider the context.
A single vote may involve hundreds of provisions.
Voting records should be examined carefully rather than reduced to one slogan.
Compare What Candidates Promise With What Their Plans Cost
During elections, candidates may promise:
Tax cuts.
New benefits.
Infrastructure.
Healthcare programs.
Education spending.
Military spending.
Debt reduction.
Citizens should ask whether those promises fit together mathematically.
If a candidate promises:
Lower taxes.
Higher spending.
And lower debt.
ask:
How?
There may be an explanation involving economic growth or spending reductions elsewhere.
Find it.
A campaign promise should eventually connect to arithmetic.
Do Not Let Your Political Party Ask the Questions for You
It is easy to scrutinize the opposing party’s spending while excusing our own.
Christians should apply the same questions regardless of who proposes the policy.
If you ask:
“How will we pay for this?”
when the other party proposes a program, ask it when your party proposes one.
If you worry about deficits under one president, continue caring under another.
If you oppose waste in one administration, oppose it in another.
Stewardship should not change when political control changes.
Debt Is Not Only the Other Party’s Problem
Government debt develops through many decisions over many years.
Spending.
Tax policy.
Economic conditions.
Wars.
Recessions.
Emergencies.
Entitlement obligations.
Interest.
Bipartisan decisions.
Christians should resist using debt merely as a weapon against political opponents.
The question is:
What path is sustainable from this point forward?
Compassion Should Survive the Budget Discussion
Numbers represent people.
A budget line may represent:
A veteran.
A child.
A person with a disability.
A police officer.
A teacher.
A widow.
A patient.
A struggling family.
A taxpayer working two jobs.
A small-business owner.
A future taxpayer who cannot vote yet.
Fiscal responsibility and compassion belong together.
Stewardship Should Survive the Compassion Discussion
Likewise, compassion does not make resources unlimited.
Poorly designed programs can waste money that could have helped people more effectively.
Fraud steals resources from legitimate needs.
Unsustainable promises can eventually collapse and hurt the very people depending upon them.
Careful stewardship protects our ability to continue helping.
Christians Can Disagree About the Answers
Two thoughtful Christians may ask all of these questions and reach different conclusions.
One may believe a tax increase is justified.
Another may believe spending should be reduced.
One may support a government program.
Another may prefer a private or local approach.
One may believe borrowing is justified for a particular investment.
Another may believe the financial risk is too great.
Scripture gives us moral principles.
It does not give us the exact tax rate, annual federal budget, city bond proposal, or design of every social program.
Therefore, we should distinguish biblical conviction from prudential judgment.
We can disagree without accusing one another of rejecting Scripture.
Practical Application
When you hear about a new spending proposal, tax plan, government program, grant, benefit, or budget, do not begin with:
“Which party proposed it?”
Begin with:
“What exactly is it?”
Then ask:
What problem is being addressed?
Is this a legitimate government responsibility?
Which level of government should handle it?
What will it cost this year?
What will it cost over time?
Where will the money come from?
Who pays?
Who benefits?
Is borrowing involved?
What interest will be paid?
Does temporary funding create permanent obligations?
Does the program duplicate something already operating?
How much goes to administration?
How will fraud be prevented?
How will success be measured?
Who independently verifies the results?
What happens if the program fails?
What happens if it succeeds?
Does it have an appropriate end date?
What incentives does it create?
Does it encourage greater stability and responsibility where possible?
Does it protect people who genuinely cannot provide for themselves?
How does it affect families?
What unintended consequences may occur?
What are the tradeoffs?
What does doing nothing cost?
What alternatives exist?
Has something similar been tried elsewhere?
What do audits and actual budgets show?
How did elected officials actually vote?
Do campaign promises fit together financially?
Then apply the same questions to politicians and policies you like as you apply to those you oppose.
That is one of the clearest tests of whether we are seeking truth or merely defending a political side.
Questions for Personal Reflection
Do I know where government money ultimately comes from?
Do I investigate what politicians mean when they say something is “free”?
Do I ask what a government proposal will cost over time?
Do I distinguish temporary spending from permanent obligations?
When taxes increase, do I investigate who is affected?
When taxes are cut, do I ask what happens to revenue, spending, deficits, and debt?
Do I understand the difference between taxes and fees?
When politicians say wealthy people or corporations will pay, do I examine the actual numbers?
When politicians promise middle-class tax relief, do I determine who actually qualifies and what changes?
Do I understand how government grants are funded and what future obligations they may create?
Do I ask whether a new program duplicates an existing one?
Do I care about administrative costs?
Do I expect safeguards against fraud and abuse?
Do I measure programs by results rather than dollars spent?
Do I ask what happens when a program fails?
Do I support review of temporary programs and emergency spending?
Do I consider government debt and interest costs?
Do I think about future generations when evaluating borrowing?
Do I examine assumptions behind budget projections?
When politicians compare spending numbers, do I ask, “Compared with what?”
Do I understand the difference between reducing projected growth and reducing actual spending?
When legislation is described as “paid for,” do I find out how?
When something is described as costing taxpayers nothing, do I investigate where the money comes from?
Do I ask who benefits and who does not qualify?
Do I understand benefits cliffs?
Do I distinguish between people who cannot work and people who can reasonably move toward greater independence?
Do I consider how programs affect work, saving, marriage, and family stability?
Do I ask whether churches, charities, businesses, families, or communities could appropriately handle part of the responsibility?
Do I consider unintended consequences?
Do I recognize policy tradeoffs?
Do I consider the cost of doing nothing?
Do I investigate alternatives?
Do I look at what happened when similar policies were tried elsewhere?
Do I read audits or budget summaries when an issue is important enough to influence my vote?
Do I follow the money rather than relying only on political advertisements?
Do I examine a politician’s actual voting record?
Do I compare campaign promises with realistic costs?
Do I apply the same financial standards to my political party that I apply to the other party?
Do I care about government debt regardless of which party controls government?
Can I combine compassion for people with concern for responsible stewardship?
Can I distinguish a biblical principle from a political judgment about the best way to apply it?
Can I disagree with another Christian about taxes or government spending without questioning that person’s faith?
Am I willing to change my opinion when reliable evidence shows that a policy is not working as I believed?
A Prayer for Wisdom About Public Money
Father, everything ultimately belongs to You, and everything entrusted to us should be handled faithfully.
Give wisdom to those who collect, budget, spend, borrow, invest, and oversee public resources.
Help government leaders remember that public money is not unlimited and that their decisions affect workers, families, businesses, communities, people in genuine need, and generations yet to come.
Give them wisdom when setting taxes.
Help them distribute burdens justly and understand how taxes affect real people.
Give them wisdom when spending.
Help them distinguish legitimate public responsibilities from unnecessary programs, wise investments from waste, and compassionate assistance from policies that unintentionally create greater problems.
Give them courage to examine programs honestly.
Expose fraud, corruption, favoritism, waste, and misuse of public resources.
Give leaders humility to change programs that are not working.
Give them foresight when borrowing so that today’s choices do not carelessly burden tomorrow’s citizens.
Help us as citizens become better stewards of our responsibility.
Keep us from believing political promises simply because they come from candidates or parties we favor.
Teach us to ask where money comes from, where it goes, what results it produces, who benefits, who pays, and what consequences may follow.
Give us compassion for those who genuinely need help.
Give us respect for taxpayers whose labor provides public resources.
Give us concern for children and future generations who will inherit today’s obligations.
Keep us from making money our god, from allowing greed to shape our political opinions, or from using concern for stewardship as an excuse to ignore our neighbors.
Help Christians who disagree about public policy treat one another with humility, patience, and love.
Above all, teach us to seek truth rather than political advantage and to use everything You have entrusted to us faithfully.
In Jesus’ name, Amen.
Related Pages
Biblical Stewardship, Government, and Personal Responsibility
Government Spending, Taxes, Debt, and Future Generations
Counting the Cost and Considering Unintended Consequences
Nothing Is Free: A Biblical View of Stewardship and Government
Continue Learning
Biblical Stewardship, Government, and Personal Responsibility
Nothing Is Free: A Biblical View of Stewardship and Government
Government Spending, Taxes, Debt, and Future Generations
Personal Responsibility, Compassion, and Government Assistance
The Roles of the Individual, Family, Church, Community, and Government
Can Government Do This—or Should Government Do This?
Counting the Cost and Considering Unintended Consequences
Questions to Ask About Spending, Taxes, Debt, and Government Programs
